If there’s anything I’m learning from playing this 1917 MLB replay, it’s that the game was played very differently (obviously) back then.

I’ve started play on day two, and in the game I’m currently playing (Senators @ Athletics), I just had the weirdest double play that I’ve ever seen:

Bases loaded, 1 out.  I try a suicide squeeze, resulting in a strikeout and the runner on third getting caught stealing home.

I think this season replay is teaching me how to play this game better, in general.  I’d ignore the solitaire charts in my 1958 replay, and slowly started using them in my 1967 replay, but I’m using them whole hog in the 1917 replay.

Day two results should be posted shortly.

Stay tuned!


Something I forgot to do before I started my 1917 MLB replay was to reverse all transactions per team, to get opening day rosters.

And because of lower limits of who gets carded in Ball Park Baseball, I’m going to have to make some creative adjustments to some of these starting lineups.

I’m almost done with Opening Day.

Stay tuned!

Perspective Addendum

If I play at the rate I played yesterday (2 games in a day), I could be finished with the 1917 season in about 2 years!  And the most games that I ever played in a day was something like 4 games, so even that time could be cut in half!

That’s not going to happen, though.  There are periods when I need to back off from one hobby and go do another, which is why I averaged about 130+ baseball games per year since I started playing regularly.

And even within the table top games hobby, I do play football, soccer and racing games too, with basketball and hockey still waiting in the wings.

So while 9 years sounds like a long time, it may be shorter (or longer) depending on what’s going on in my life.

I will get this one done, though.  Someday.  Just not tomorrow.  Or next month.

As an aside I will say it’s quite a thing to see names in these lineups of players who are the legends of baseball, like Babe Ruth pitching for the Red Sox, or Ty Cobb striking out against Stan Coveleski.  Tris Speaker.  Wally Pipp.  Names of players who I’ve heard of, but never really knew.  After the two games I played Thursday night, I found myself looking up some of the players online to see what their careers were like.  It surprised me to find that Coveleski was a Hall of Famer, who used the spitball.  Pipp’s name rang a bell, and I confirmed online that this was the fella who Lou Gehrig replaced on the Yankees.

Forever a student of this game, that’s me.

Stay tuned!


It has taken me a little less than 3  years to play about 400 games of table top baseball.

I have over 1200 more games to play in just the 1917 season alone.

So even if I were to focus on just that replay project, it would take me a little under 9 more years to complete it.

I’ll give myself until December 2027 to get it done, just to stay on the safe side.

Stay tuned!

Ball Park Baseball: 1917

I seem to find a new thing about this game whenever I start a new project.  A chart that I should have been looking at more often is what I usually find.

This time I’m actually taking the time to check the solitaire strategy charts which I should have been using, but didn’t.

It’s mostly because I’m playing games in 1917, the Deadball Era, where most runs were scored by what SF Giants broadcasters call the Ground Attack: bunts, steals, simply putting the ball in play and not relying on the longball.  I need these charts to keep me honest, and truth be told, I don’t call for most of the regular Ground Attack strategy, like sacrifice bunts or hit and run plays.  Heck, I hardly call for a steal of second, but that changes now.

Through two and a half innings, the Indians and Tigers are tied 0-0 with 1 hit for each team.  It’s been mostly ground outs, with one ball leaving the infield for a fly out.

Bottom line is that I have to adjust my style of play for 1917 baseball.

Stay tuned!